Former Foreign Secretary James Cleverly criticizes proposed changes to the assisted dying bill, accusing proponents of using 'Orwellian' language to mask a significant weakening of safeguards. The bill's sponsor, Labour MP Kim Leadbeater, has floated the idea of replacing High Court judge oversight with a panel of experts, sparking concerns about a decline in robust protection.
James Cleverly has criticized the assisted dying bill, labelling it 'Orwellian' following the proposal to remove the requirement for high-court judge approval. The Conservative former Foreign Secretary expressed his concerns on LBC's Tonight with Andrew Marr, stating that when the bill passed its second reading in the House of Commons, its sponsor, Labour MP Kim Leadbeater, had assured the public of 'incredibly robust protection.
' However, concerns arose regarding the significant strain on judicial resources posed by requiring a senior judge to sign off on each case. Consequently, Ms. Leadbeater suggested an alternative involving a panel of experts, such as psychologists or social workers, making the final decision. This 'judge plus' model, according to Mr. Cleverly, constitutes a misleading use of language. He argued that the proponents of the bill, including Ms. Leadbeater, had repeatedly emphasized the robust protection regime, including the judicial process, during the second reading debate. Yet, just weeks later, with the prospect of downgrading this safeguard, they vehemently defended the need for a High Court Judge's involvement.Mr. Cleverly, who also participated in the post-election Tory leadership race, believes the legislation, currently a private member's bill, should be taken over by the government to allow for more comprehensive scrutiny by MPs. He asserts that a private member's bill presents numerous limitations for such a complex and sensitive matter. He urges for it to be transitioned into a government bill, ensuring it receives the thorough examination it deserves. Mr. Cleverly concludes by stating his reservations about the current direction and emphasizing the importance of enacting high-quality legislation if the bill ultimately becomes law. He cautions against rushing the process and advocates for a measured approach that prioritizes careful consideration
ASSISTED DYING LEGISLATION HIGH COURT JUDGE EXPERT PANEL KIM LEADBEATER JAMES CLEVERLY ORWELLIAN PARLIAMENTARY SCRUTINY
United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Assisted Dying Bill: Timeline and SafeguardsProfessor Sir Chris Whitty, England's chief medical officer, believes assisted dying legislation could be implemented within two years. He emphasizes that the process should not be rushed and advocates for simplicity in safeguards. The Bill, which could allow terminally ill adults to legally end their lives, is currently under scrutiny by a parliamentary committee.
Read more »
Assisted Dying Bill in Scotland Faces Opposition from Disability GroupA proposal to legalize assisted dying in Scotland has sparked concerns among a disability rights advocacy group, which warns of potential unintended consequences for vulnerable individuals.
Read more »
Assisted Dying Bill: Judge Plus System Proposed Amidst Legal System ConcernsThe Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill, aiming to legalize assisted dying for terminally ill adults in England and Wales, may see changes to its original plan involving High Court judge approval. Concerns about the potential burden on the legal system have prompted Labour MP Kim Leadbeater to propose a 'judge plus' system, featuring a Voluntary Assisted Dying Commission led by a judge. This commission would involve psychiatrists, social workers, and independent doctors to ensure robust safeguards and voluntary decision-making.
Read more »
Assisted Dying Bill: Judge Approval Could Be DroppedKim Leadbeater, Labour MP, proposes a 'judge plus' system for the Terminally Ill Adults (End of Life) Bill to avoid overwhelming the legal system. The proposed system involves a Voluntary Assisted Dying Commission led by a High Court judge, with a panel reviewing applications for assisted death. The changes aim to balance patient autonomy with robust safeguards, addressing concerns about coercion and capacity.
Read more »
Assisted Dying Bill Amended: Multi-Disciplinary Panels to Review CasesLabour MP Kim Leadbeater proposes amendments to her Assisted Dying Bill, replacing High Court judge approval with multi-disciplinary panels of experts. This 'judge plus' system aims to strengthen safeguards against coercion while involving professionals like psychiatrists and social workers. Critics argue the change weakens safeguards, calling it 'a disgrace' and 'badly thought out legislation'.
Read more »
Assisted Dying Bill: Panel of Experts to Replace JudgeLabour MP and Assisted Dying Bill proposer, Leadbeater, has suggested replacing a High Court judge with a panel of experts in the eligibility assessment process for assisted dying. This change comes amid concerns about potential court overload and follows extensive witness testimony during the bill committee stage.
Read more »