The UK Government is appealing against a court order to hold a public inquiry into the murder of Sean Brown, a senior GAA official killed by loyalist paramilitaries in 1997. The Government argues that the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR) is a more suitable body to investigate the case.
A judge was wrong in law to order the Government to hold a public inquiry into the murder of a senior GAA official during the Troubles , a court has heard. Belfast High Court judge Justice Humphreys “seized the discretion” held by Northern Ireland Secretary Hilary Benn and exercised it himself when he ordered an inquiry into Sean Brown’s death, a Government barrister claimed.
In a Court of Appeal challenge against the ruling, Tony McGleenan KC characterised the judge’s decision as unprecedented, highlighting that there had never been another instance of a court making an order of mandamus compelling the Government to hold a public inquiry. “There’s not a single example anyone will show you of a court doing that,” he told the Appeal Court judges. Mr Brown, the 61-year-old chairman of Bellaghy Wolfe Tones GAA club in Co Derry, was ambushed, kidnapped and murdered by loyalist paramilitaries as he locked the gates of the club in May 1997. No-one has ever been convicted of his killing. Stormont First Minister and Sinn Fein vice president Michelle O’Neill and SDLP leader Claire Hanna were among supporters who accompanied the Brown family to the Court of Appeal in Belfast on Thursday to hear the Government’s appeal against the public inquiry order. Last year, a coroner halted an inquest into the death, expressing concern that his ability to examine the case had been “compromised” by the extent of confidential state material being excluded from the proceedings on national security grounds. Preliminary inquest proceedings had already heard that in excess of 25 people had been linked by intelligence to the murder, including several state agents. It had also been alleged in court that surveillance of a suspect in the murder was temporarily stopped on the evening of the killing, only to resume again the following morning. Coroner Mr Justice Kinney called on the Government to establish a public inquiry into the loyalist murder. Mr Benn decided against holding an inquiry, arguing that the case could instead be dealt with by a new Troubles investigatory body, the Independent Commission for Reconciliation and Information Recovery (ICRIR). However, aspects of the legislation that underpins the work of the ICRIR was later found incompatible with human rights laws in a different Court of Appeal challenge separate to the Brown case. Mr Brown’s widow Bridie challenged Mr Benn’s decision not to order a public inquiry and Justice Humphreys found in her favour in December and ordered the Government to establish one. Northern Ireland’s Lady Chief Justice Dame Siobhan Keegan joined two other Court of Appeal judges – Lord Justice Treacy and Lord Justice Horner – in hearing the case on Thursday. Representing the Government, Mr McGleenan suggested that ordering a public inquiry was premature as he insisted Mr Benn remained committed to making the ICRIR compliant with human rights laws – either by legislative changes or by successfully challenging the separate Court of Appeal judgment at the Supreme Court. The barrister said Justice Humphreys should have adjourned Mrs Brown’s case until the outcome of the appeal over the ICRIR’s compliance ran its course. During exchanges in court, Lord Justice Treacy told Mr McGleenan that a judge’s job was to make a ruling based on the state of the law at the time, and not on what the legal position might look like in the future. He suggested that a public inquiry was the “only show in town” in terms of a human rights compliant investigation when the judgment was handed down, as he predicted that Government moves to make the ICRIC compliant could take years. Mr McGleenan insisted that the ICRIR would be made human rights compliant “by hook or by crook” and it could then deal with the Brown case “faster and cheaper” than a public inquiry. He said Justice Humphreys was aware of the Government’s commitment to make the ICRIR compliant when he ordered the public inquiry. Noting the family’s long wait for justice, the barrister acknowledged that it was “not a comfortable position” for the Government to be mounting the appeal challenge. But he maintained that Justice Humphreys should not have ordered a public inquiry while the issues of “considerable importance” around the ICRIR’s ability to hold a compliant investigation were still unresolved
PUBLIC INQUIRY TROUBLES IRA GAA JUSTICE LAW APPEAL NORTHERN IRELAND
United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Young GAA Volunteer Sophia Walsh Receives Translink Ulster GAA Young Volunteer of the Month AwardSophia Walsh, a 15-year-old from St Mary's GAC Aghagallon in Co Antrim, has been awarded the Translink Ulster GAA Young Volunteer of the Month for September 2024 for her outstanding dedication to her club and community.
Read more »
Family of Murdered GAA Official Seeks Public Inquiry in Belfast High CourtThe daughter and widow of Sean Brown, a GAA official murdered by the LVF in 1997, are seeking a public inquiry into his death at Belfast High Court. The case highlights the ongoing legacy of the Troubles and the demand for truth and justice.
Read more »
UK Government to Block Troubles Internee Compensation After Court RulingSir Keir Starmer, the UK's Leader of the Opposition, stated that the government is committed to exploring all possible avenues to prevent former Troubles internees, including Gerry Adams, from receiving compensation. The Prime Minister criticized the Northern Ireland Troubles (Legacy and Reconciliation) Act 2023, stating his intention to replace it with legislation that prevents such payouts. Conservative Party leader Kemi Badenoch expressed strong disapproval of the potential for compensation for Adams.
Read more »
High Court Rules Government Consultation on Disability Benefits Reforms UnlawfulThe High Court ruled that the UK government's consultation on plans to reform disability benefits was unlawful. The court found that the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) failed to adequately explain the significant reduction in benefits that many disabled and chronically ill people would face under the proposed changes. Campaigners celebrated the ruling, urging the Labour government to abandon the reforms and prioritize the well-being of disabled benefit claimants.
Read more »
Massachusetts Supreme Court to Weigh Public Access to Juvenile Court Records in Harmony Montgomery CaseThe Massachusetts Supreme Judicial Court will hear arguments Monday in a case about whether records from the custody hearings for Harmony Montgomery, a 5-year-old girl who was slain in 2019, should be made public. Filmmaker Bill Lichtenstein, who is producing a documentary on the Massachusetts child protection and juvenile court systems, appealed to the high court seeking access to the records. He hopes they will shed light on why Harmony's father was granted custody despite his violent criminal history.
Read more »
Casement Park Redevelopment to Continue in 2025Ulster GAA will continue demolition work at Casement Park in 2025, refocusing on a more modest rebuild after the UK Government withdrew funding for the original project. Despite the setback, Ulster GAA secured €50 million from the Government of Ireland Shared Island Fund, bringing their total contribution to approximately £58 million. Demolition of the old stand is planned for the new year.
Read more »