Dundee United FC has formally withdrawn its representation from the Key Match Incident Review (KMI) panel, citing concerns over its effectiveness and impact on Scottish football. The withdrawal follows similar calls for change by St Mirren, who advocate for an independent body to oversee VAR. The KMI panel, comprising club representatives, former officials, ex-players, managers, and media figures, reviews controversial refereeing and VAR incidents. United believes the panel's outcomes have been inconsistent with feedback from the SFA, and that disagreements stem from panel members lacking practical experience in the game.
A controversial panel reviewing key match incidents (KMI) in Scottish football has sparked debate after Dundee United withdrew its representation. The club expressed concerns about the panel's purpose, effectiveness, and impact on the sport, citing inconsistencies in its outcomes and disagreements with on-field decisions supported by VAR . United's move follows similar calls from St Mirren for an independent body to oversee VAR , instead of the Scottish Football Association (SFA).
The KMI panel, consisting of club representatives, former officials, ex-players, managers, and media figures, reviews controversial refereeing and VAR incidents. According to Record Sport, BBC commentators and Sky Sports pundits have been among those asked for their opinions, alongside some written press, all contributing to the KMI's findings. The panel was introduced to enhance transparency surrounding VAR, but has instead generated friction.The SFA's referee chief, Willie Collum, has issued a series of apologies to clubs following high-profile officiating errors. Some KMI independent reviews have also clashed with club officials, who argue that some panel members lack practical experience in the game. Both United and St Mirren are seeking discussions with the SFA after feeling aggrieved by decisions in recent matches. United felt goalkeeper Jack Walton was fouled for Marley Watkins' goal at Kilmarnock, while St Mirren believed they were denied a penalty for a foul on Elvis Bwomono. These incidents have fueled calls for Scottish football to reconsider VAR, with some fans advocating for its removal, mirroring the approach taken by their Swedish counterparts. The SFA has been approached for comment
Scottish Football VAR KMI Panel Dundee United St Mirren
United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Dundee United Suffer 'Avoidable Controversy' in Scottish Cup LossFormer referee Keith Hackett criticizes referee Matthew MacDermid for blowing his whistle prematurely during Dundee United's Scottish Cup defeat to their rivals. The decision disallowed a potential equalizing goal by Vicko Sevelj, leaving Hackett to believe the incident was avoidable.
Read more »
Dundee United vs Rangers: Scottish Premiership Clash - Live Stream, TV Coverage, Team News, Kick-Off TimeDundee United and Rangers are set for a crucial Scottish Premiership encounter this Sunday. Don't miss out on the live action, TV coverage, team news, and more.
Read more »
Mohamed Diomande red card: Rangers' appeal over Dundee United dismissal successful after Scottish FA hearingRangers' appeal over the red card shown to Mohamed Diomande at Dundee United has been successful.
Read more »
Dundee United Withdraw From VAR Review Panel, Citing Concerns Over Inconsistent InterpretationsDundee United have formally withdrawn their representation from the KMI (Key Match Incident) panel, citing concerns about the panel's effectiveness, inconsistencies, and lack of expertise in the laws of the game. The club believes VAR implementations have led to inconsistent interpretations and amplified scrutiny on refereeing decisions.
Read more »
Dundee United Boycotts VAR Review Panel Over 'Lack of Trust'Dundee United has announced its refusal to participate in the Scottish FA's video assistant referee (VAR) review panel, citing a lack of trust in the process. The club expressed concerns about the panel's purpose, effectiveness, and impact on Scottish football, alleging inconsistencies between feedback from the SFA's refereeing department and the panel's verdicts. United claims some decisions appear to be based on opinions rather than expertise in the laws of the game, potentially influencing referee decision-making. The club also highlighted recent VAR decisions they deemed erroneous, such as allowing a disputed Kilmarnock goal and not awarding a penalty for a handball. Dundee United has called for changes to the VAR review process or the implementation of a more robust alternative.
Read more »
VAR Controversy: Dundee United Penalty Decision Sparks DebateKeith Hackett, a former Premier League referee, has weighed in on the controversial VAR decision not to overturn a penalty awarded to St. Mirren against Dundee United. Despite minimal contact, the decision was made by referee David Dickinson based on Kevin Holt's defensive positioning. Although Olusanya missed the resulting penalty, the incident ignited debate about VAR's role in officiating.
Read more »