A complex, multi-state legal battle over Enbridge's Line 5 pipeline continues to intensify, with courts, tribes, and governments clashing over environmental risks, jurisdiction, and energy security.
Active lawsuits in Michigan and Wisconsin are targeting sections of Enbridge 's Line 5 pipeline over environmental concerns in a complex and ever-expanding legal fight. Michigan has an active state-court lawsuit against Enbridge , while in Wisconsin, the Bad River Band of Lake Superior Chippewa and environmental groups are challenging the pipeline in federal and state court.
In April, the United States Supreme Court sided with Michigan that a ruling over a section of an ageing pipeline beneath a Great Lakes channel must stay in state court. Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote on behalf of a unanimous court that while the Calgary-based energy firm Enbridge was permitted 30 days to attempt to move the case to federal court, the company instead waited 887 days to do so, and only after it had seen developments in related litigation over the Line 5 pipeline.
In June 2019, Michigan's attorney general, Dana Nessel, sued in state court to void the easement that permits Enbridge to operate a 4.5-mile section of pipeline under the Straits of Mackinac, which link Lake Michigan and Lake Huron. The pipeline has been transporting crude and natural gas since 1953 and currently transports 540,000 bpd of crude and refined products from Superior, Wisconsin, to Sarnia, Ontario.
Enbridge moved to take the lawsuit to federal court in 2021 on the grounds that the case affects U.S. and Canadian trade. In a statement, Nessel said the ruling 'makes emphatically clear that our lawsuit against Enbridge belongs before the state court, where we've argued since 2019 that Line 5 does not have a legal right to the Straits bottomlands.
' The justification for the pipeline case, referred to as Line 5, is the potential for the section beneath the straits to rupture, which could cause a catastrophic spill. Experts first raised the concern in 2017, after Enbridge engineers admitted that they had been aware of the gaps in the section's protective coating since 2014. A boat anchor further damaged the section in 2018, increasing concerns around a potential spill.
Nessel has called the section of pipeline 'a ticking time bomb in the heart of the Great Lakes.
' State officials have also argued that Enbridge has violated state laws, including the Michigan Environmental Protection Act. Nessel has previously won a restraining order in June 2020, resulting in Enbridge shutting down the pipeline from Ingham County.
However, Enbridge has since improved safety operations and been permitted to recommence operations. The Michigan Department of Natural Resources, led by Governor Gretchen Whitmer, revoked the easement for Line 5 in 2020, after which Enbridge filed a separate federal lawsuit to challenge the move. A federal judge ruled in favour of Enbridge, holding that the federal Pipeline Safety Act preempts Michigan's attempt to shut down the pipeline on safety grounds.
Whitmer then appealed to the Sixth U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals. In March 2026, the Supreme Court denied Whitmer's petition for certiorari on sovereign immunity, allowing Enbridge's federal lawsuit against her to proceed. In 2023, the Michigan Public Service Commission granted Enbridge the necessary permits to encase the section of pipeline in a protective tunnel to ensure safety and prevent a shutdown.
However, work has not gone ahead on the project as a coalition of environmental groups and Michigan tribes has filed a lawsuit to cancel the state permits. This issue will be considered during the state court case. To move forward with the project, Enbridge must also seek approval from the U.S. Army Corps of Engineers and the Michigan Department of the Environment, Great Lakes and Energy. Separately, a lawsuit was filed in Wisconsin over the pipeline.
In June 2023, a federal judge ordered that Enbridge must shut down part of Line 5 that runs across the Bad River Band of Lake Superior's reservation within three years. Enbridge appealed the order, and in February of this year, it commenced work to reroute the line around the reservation. The Bad River Band and environmental groups have since filed a lawsuit to halt work on the project over environmental concerns.
The ongoing legal battle has raised broader questions over how much power states hold in exerting control over the fossil fuel industry. The dispute has also put pressure on United States-Canada energy relations.
In addition, the battle over the pipeline has scrambled traditional political alliances due to the large number of jobs connected with pipeline operations, as well as the industry it brings to the region. After battling the issue for several years, neither Enbridge nor state lawmakers are backing down in the pipeline case, suggesting that it could take more time to resolve.
In the meantime, Enbridge has been unable to progress on its project to encase the section of pipeline in Michigan, while the pipeline continues to pose a potential threat to the environment. By Felicity Bradstock for Oilprice.com
Enbridge Michigan Lawsuit Wisconsin Pipeline Bad River Band Great Lakes Environmental Risk Pipeline Safety Energy Policy US-Canada Relations
United States Latest News, United States Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
St George's Day parade makes its way though Manchester in 'biggest and best' everHuge crowds gathered in the city centre today to watch as the 'biggest and best' St George's Day parade passed through
Read more »
I never shop at Co-op but underrated item is the best everI've tried shopping at all the major supermarkets, but there's one Co-op product I keep going back to – and it tastes genuinely restaurant-quality
Read more »
Work starts on new £98k Netherfield play area with 25-metre zip lineThe new facilities at Jackie Bell's Field in Netherfield will be ready in time for summer
Read more »
How Man United should line up vs Brentford in Premier League fixtureManchester United welcome Brentford to Old Trafford on Monday night as they aim to take another step towards Champions League qualification
Read more »
Dad collapsed metres from Manchester Marathon finish line with 'swollen brain'Dom Dozier has issued a warning to anyone thinking of tackling a marathon
Read more »
London Marathon final finishers cheered home to finish lineThe last finishers to cross the line were met by enthusiastic supporters
Read more »