A group of 58 experts has called into question the reliability of Body Mass Index (BMI) as a primary indicator of health and weight status, urging a shift towards more comprehensive assessment methods.
The long-standing reliance on Body Mass Index ( BMI ) as a primary measure of weight and health is facing criticism from a group of 58 experts who argue that it is an unreliable indicator and needs to be replaced with more comprehensive assessment methods.
While BMI, calculated by dividing weight in kilograms by the square of height in meters, provides a general indication of weight status, categorizing individuals as underweight, normal weight, overweight, or obese based on specific BMI ranges, it fails to capture the complexities of individual health.This conclusion stems from the work of the Commission on Clinical Obesity, which published its findings in the medical journal, The Lancet. The commission highlights several limitations of BMI. Firstly, it does not consider the distribution of body fat. Fat stored primarily in the abdomen, known as abdominal obesity, poses a greater health risk than fat evenly distributed throughout the body. Measuring waist circumference, waist-to-height ratio, or waist-to-hip ratio provides a more accurate assessment of abdominal obesity. Secondly, BMI does not account for underlying health conditions that may be exacerbated or caused by obesity, such as joint pain or shortness of breath.The commission proposes a new approach to classifying obesity, dividing it into two categories: clinical obesity, where individuals have associated health conditions, and pre-clinical obesity, where they do not. This distinction would allow for a more targeted and effective treatment approach, prioritizing access to obesity treatments, such as weight loss injections, for those with clinical obesity. Additionally, the commission emphasizes that BMI does not differentiate between weight from fat and muscle mass, potentially misclassifying muscular individuals, such as athletes, as obese. The commission's recommendations have garnered support from numerous obesity experts globally. However, the practical implementation of these recommendations remains to be seen. While recording height and weight is simple, incorporating additional measurements like waist circumference requires more time and effort. Nonetheless, the emergence of weight loss injections as a transformative obesity treatment, with increasing availability on the NHS, underscores the need for more accurate methods of assessing the impact of weight on health
BMI Obesity Health Weight Management Clinical Obesity Pre-Clinical Obesity Waist Circumference Body Fat Distribution
United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Push to ditch BMI as sole obesity measure to end 'unnecessary' weight-loss jabsA new Lancet Commission - made up of more than 50 experts from around the world - said that a 'radical overhaul' is needed in how obesity is diagnosed
Read more »
More Than BMI: Understanding Biological Age and Health IndicatorsThis article explores the concept of biological age and its significance for overall health. It delves into various health indicators beyond BMI, such as blood pressure, cholesterol levels, and waist-to-hip ratio, highlighting their importance in assessing an individual's health status.
Read more »
Forget BMI and 10,000 Steps: What Really Matters for Your HealthThis article debunks common health myths and offers expert advice on what truly contributes to well-being. It challenges the notion of 10,000 steps a day and BMI as definitive indicators of health, emphasizing the importance of increasing activity levels and overall fitness.
Read more »
Forget BMI, 10,000 Steps and Suncream: What REALLY Matters for Your HealthPersonal trainer Amy Snelling busts common health myths, including the 10,000 steps a day target and the importance of BMI, highlighting the real factors that contribute to better health.
Read more »
Prioritize Your Health This New Year with Randox HealthRandox Health encourages a proactive approach to well-being in the New Year, emphasizing personalized health checks as a key to achieving meaningful wellness goals.
Read more »
Lidl's Health-Boosting Yoghurt Could Improve Gut Health and Reduce CholesterolLidl has launched a new yoghurt called Proviact, which contains bifidobacteria, a beneficial bacteria that may improve gut health, ease IBS symptoms, and lower cholesterol levels. The yoghurt is available for £1.65 for four pots and comes in rhubarb and strawberry flavours.
Read more »