The UK government's procurement of digital services has been criticized by the National Audit Office (NAO) for lacking sufficient technical feasibility assessments. The report highlights how Whitehall departments often create business cases for new IT projects without proper technical input, leading to potential problems down the line. The NAO calls for improvements to the current collaborative approach and a more strategic approach from the center of government to ensure efficient and effective delivery of digital services.
The UK government's approach to purchasing technology has been criticized for its lack of technical feasibility assessments, according to a spending watchdog's analysis of the £14 billion-a-year procurement of digital services .
The National Audit Office (NAO) report, which evaluates the government's dealings with technology suppliers, highlights how Whitehall departments create business cases for new IT projects and procurement without sufficient technical input, leading to problems down the line that can be difficult to resolve. The report states: 'Current government processes from business case development to contract award do not work well for digital programs. Departments can present investment cases without a detailed assessment of technical feasibility, for which there is no detailed central government guidance. Without such assessments, funding allocation at the center can be based on departments' conceptual or simplistic high-level assumptions.' This results in limited technical evaluation of contracts with technical risks downplayed. Complexities which emerge after contracts are signed can be too fundamental to be dealt with through a change control process. A poorly defined requirement and an overemphasis on acquiring the minimum requirement or cheapest resource.' Responding to the report, Geoffrey Clifton-Brown, MP and chair of Parliament's spending watchdog, the Public Accounts Committee, said the government's handling of major digital programs had led to delays and costs to the taxpayer. 'Digital commercial skills are in short supply and government is not making the most of the limited expertise it has. Government has managed digital suppliers poorly, and the center of government has not provided direction to help departments become intelligent clients,' he said. 'The Public Accounts Committee has long maintained that technology can transform the way government delivers public services. Without a more strategic approach from the center, and a sourcing strategy that is fit for purpose for the digital age, the government risks wasting more money and squandering the opportunity to modernize the public sector.' In these projects, the public sector spending watchdog found that government's commercial approach to selecting and working with suppliers contributed to difficulties in their programs, causing significant delays to modernization (totaling at least 29 years), and with more than £3 billion in cost increases (at least 26 percent of the original forecast), requiring a reset of the programs concerned and continuing to operate legacy systems for longer than planned. The NAO's report says that the government had yet to create a unified strategy to approach a few very large suppliers who now dominate technology markets. The NAO called for improvements to the current collaborative central approach established by the Central Digital & Data Office (CDDO), the Crown Commercial Service, and the Government Commercial Function (GCF). 'The GCF has to cover a large spectrum of commercial activity and does not have the extent of digital skills needed to reflect the distinct procurement challenges of digital programs and operations,' the report states. 'CDDO leads on digital and data policy but, while it has relevant digital expertise, it does not have responsibility for digital procurement in government, is much smaller than GCF, and is not resourced for more extensive engagement on digital procurement. Non-technical leaders are not given enough digital procurement support to manage digital change programs effectively. This lack of specialist digital commercial focus creates major challenges to the efficient and effective organization, delivery, and ongoing maintenance of government services and their related digital infrastructure.' The NAO also found that central government departments often enter into digital and technology contracts without sufficiently understanding the complexities posed by the existing environment. 'Setting requirements for digital programs can be particularly difficult, but pressure to deliver quickly can result in contracts being awarded before the true requirement is fully understood,' it said
UK Government Technology Procurement Digital Services National Audit Office (NAO) Technical Feasibility Whitehall Departments Contract Award Digital Transformation Public Sector Government Commercial Function (GCF) Central Digital & Data Office (CDDO)
United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Darts Fans Criticized For 'Mind Games' and Taunting of Cameron MenziesThe behavior of some spectators at Ally Pally during Cameron Menzies' match against Leonard Gates has sparked criticism. Menzies was subjected to taunts and chants, which some see as going too far in creating a 'party atmosphere'.
Read more »
Man City vs Man Utd: Haaland Criticized and Player RatingsThis article analyzes the recent Manchester City vs Manchester United game, focusing on Erling Haaland's performance and discussing other players' strengths and weaknesses. It also speculates on the future of players like Rashford and Mount.
Read more »
Police Response to UK Riots Criticized in New ReportA new report by HMICFRS criticizes the police response to the summer riots in the UK, finding that they failed to adequately assess the rising tide of violence and misinformation.
Read more »
Celtic Sponsorship Deal Criticized by Football ExecutiveFormer Aberdeen CEO Keith Wyness believes Celtic could have been more ambitious with their sponsorship deal renewal with Dafabet.
Read more »
Children's Carol Service Criticized for 'Promoting Christianity'A children's carol service organized by a housing association in England was criticized for promoting Christianity, despite tenants overwhelmingly supporting the event.
Read more »
Swindon Christmas Market Criticized by ResidentsThe newly opened Swindon Christmas Market has faced backlash from residents who say it has failed to attract visitors and is negatively impacting the town centre.
Read more »