A passionate rant about football's inability to properly manage timekeeping, even with advanced technology like VAR and 3D offside analysis. The author argues that simple solutions like stopping the clock for incidents like injuries and VAR reviews would create a fairer and more transparent game.
Submitting your details indicates your consent for The Mag to send you email marketing messages and process personal data. Please read our privacy policy. It has always amazed me how football looks to complicated and expensive technological solutions to solve seemingly simple problems. Each ground is covered by a dozen (or possibly dozens of) cameras. The pictures are beamed via satellite to a remote central location to be viewed by a team of VAR officials.
In turn, they flag potential issues to the referee on the field via his radio-headset. As required, the footage is then beamed back through the satellite network to the ground for the referee to review on a pitch-side monitor. It’s almost too simple for words. For possible offside incidents, the officials can fall back on sophisticated video technology to create a real-time 3D computer image of the players and how their bodies are positioned at the exact instant the attacking team kicks the ball. They can then run a computer-generated line. If the moving line hits the attacking player before the defending player, the referee is told to call offside via that radio-controlled headset. Again, this is a devastatingly simple system to call upon and operate… Not! How much did these toys cost the football authorities? I bet it was a damn sight more than the cost of a stopwatch. In the recent away match against the Saints, we saw Isak bundled over and several minutes tick away on the game clock whilst the VAR officials did their funky stuff. bring the score back to 3-2. This time there’s a sniff of offside and another who-knows-how-long ticks away whilst the 3D modelling program runs. By the end of the match, almost 10 minutes of additional time is added across the two halves. One minute lost for each nine minutes of play? Really? For both of these incidents, I am left open-mouthed that no one thought to stop the clock. Even Wednesday’s game against Arsenal saw nine minutes added across the 90. One minute lost for every 10 minutes that passed on the game clock? Again, REALLY? Why nine minutes? Why not only two minutes? Or perhaps it should have been 20? Who knows? I bet the guy that held up the boards didn’t have the first clue where the number came from. As Newcastle United fans, how many times have we seen our team apparently swindled out of a great result due to ridiculously long periods of “Additional Minutes”?; a VERY dodgy penalty awarded in the 90+9th minute. Similarly, there was the infamous 2-1 defeat at Anfield in 2022; a winner for the scousers coming in the 90+7th minute. To add insult to injury, I think we all understand the unwritten rule that states “additional time will be played until Manchester United have snatched that all-important deciding goal.” The footballing authorities would have us believe that VAR and the offside technologies were introduced to provide transparency to the decisions on the pitch. If transparency mattered, why are we continually left bemused and frustrated by these long periods of time-added-on? The laws of the game are pretty clear as to what incidents the referee should add time on for. So, it’s not as if the clock will stop ad nauseum every time a player sneezes. Stoppages for treatment to injured players, VAR and offside reviews are clear-cut candidates for “stop the clock”. With a T-sign to the timekeeper, the referee could easily signal when the clock should be stopped. If the ball is technically still in play, he can use his discretion and signal the clock to stop to deal with timewasting, etc. The match clock starts again when play resumes or the referee signals. Now that really is simple! In the past, I have heard the argument that stopping the clock for every ball out-of-play could seriously over-extend the game. My response… so what? Many years ago, I was a regular at Whitley Bay and Durham ice rinks to watch the Warriors and the Wasps respectively. I regularly saw one hour games last over three hours; but stopping the clock guaranteed the full 60 minutes of game-time for the paying spectators. In the dim and distant past, my father was an accredited basketball referee. His arm raised instantly stopped the clock and no game time was lost. On Sunday, the Super Bowl stopped their clock every time play stopped. The list of sports that keep proper time is almost endless. In each case, the duration of the match is transparent; teams and spectators all fully aware of time played and time remaining. We may be in the 21st century, but football is still in the dark ages of “stick finger in air, scratch chin, take away the number you first thought of” when it comes to deciding how much time to add on at the end of each hal
Football VAR Offside Timekeeping Transparency Sports Commentary Newcastle United
United Kingdom Latest News, United Kingdom Headlines
Similar News:You can also read news stories similar to this one that we have collected from other news sources.
Norway's Football Fans Celebrate 'Big Win' Against VAR TechnologySupporters' groups in Norway are celebrating a significant victory in their campaign against the use of VAR (Video Assistant Referee) technology in the Eliteserien, the country's top football league. Hundreds of fans have protested against VAR since its implementation in January 2023, with disruptions to matches involving flares, smoke bombs, and even fish cakes being thrown onto the pitch. With members from 18 of the top 32 clubs voting in favor of scrapping the technology, anti-VAR sentiment is now in the majority.
Read more »
Norwegian Football Fans Score Major Victory Against VARSupporters' groups in Norway have emerged victorious in their campaign to remove VAR from the Eliteserien, securing a majority vote among top clubs.
Read more »
VAR Overhaul: Two Simple Ideas To Improve Football's Controversial SystemThe author proposes two innovative solutions to address the persistent issues surrounding VAR (Video Assistant Referee) in professional football. These ideas aim to reduce disruptions, increase transparency, and ultimately enhance the viewing experience for fans.
Read more »
Dundee United Withdraws from Controversial Scottish Football VAR PanelDundee United FC has formally withdrawn its representation from the Key Match Incident Review (KMI) panel, citing concerns over its effectiveness and impact on Scottish football. The withdrawal follows similar calls for change by St Mirren, who advocate for an independent body to oversee VAR. The KMI panel, comprising club representatives, former officials, ex-players, managers, and media figures, reviews controversial refereeing and VAR incidents. United believes the panel's outcomes have been inconsistent with feedback from the SFA, and that disagreements stem from panel members lacking practical experience in the game.
Read more »
Become a Director of Football in Football ManagerThis guide shows you how to create a Director of Football mode within Football Manager, even though it's not an official feature. Learn how to delegate tasks to your Assistant Manager and focus solely on transfers.
Read more »
North East football fans say football regulator must be effectiveThe government says a regulator is required to protect fans but the premier league has concerns.
Read more »